Where is the grown-up right ?

In thinking about the likely role of bloggers in the forthcoming election, I thought I’d start by looking at the listing of Oz political bloggers put up by Ken Parish, which is about the most comprehensive there is. What’s immediately apparent is the almost complete absence of any serious contribution from supporters of the Liberals.

Ken divides his ‘right-of-centre’ bloggers into two groups, “moderate” and “right-wing death beasts[1]”. The distinction isn’t so much in terms of views on policy issues, but in terms of style and focus. The RWDBs adopt a consciously over-the-top style, in imitation of overseas models like Mark Steyn, and seem more attached to George Bush and the US Republican Party than to Howard and the Liberals. Even with an Australian election campaign under way, many of them are still more concerned with the US than with Australian issues. More importantly, they focus remorselessly on trivial political talking points (did Kerry really deserve his Purple Heart, making fun of Latham’s health problems ) than on anything likely to concern the Australian electorate.

Turning to Ken’s “moderate right” category, he has only ten names, and most of these are either inactive or misclassified. In looking at his list, and others, the only serious bloggers I could think of on the political right were c8to , Andrew Norton of Catallaxy and John Humphreys, all of whom are more libertarian than Liberal[2].

It wasn’t always so. When I started this blog in 2002, about half of the bloggers I linked to regularly were members of the moderate right, including David Morgan, Gareth Parker, Scott Wickstein and Jason Soon. Even Tim Blair wasn’t as stereotypically an RWDB as he is now. But Morgan and Parker have given up blogging, Wickstein now sticks almost exclusively to football and Soon has moved to the political centre. Meanwhile, RWDB sites have proliferated, as is indicated by Ken’s blogroll. There seems to something in the medium that’s not conducive to the politics of the centre-right.

This is quite different from the mainstream media. Of course, radio is full of shock jocks and print has its McGuinnesses and Akermans, but there are also lots of serious supporters of the Liberals and the political right more broadly, including Alan Wood, Christopher Pearson, Gerard Henderson and Miranda Devine, to name only a few.

Overall, to the extent that the blogosphere has any impact, this situation has to be bad for the Liberals. I can’t imagine that many undecided voters are going to be swayed by the offerings of the RWDB brigade, except in the opposite direction. Meanwhile, with the blog audience growing rapidly, the left of Ozplogistan may have an influence, if mainly an indirect one.

Now, I’m sure that commenters can point to some serious contributors overlooked, or misclassified, in Ken’s listing. I’ll concede in advance that some members of the RWDB group are less cartoonish than others. I haven’t waded through all the sites in the list. In addition, it’s true that some leftwing blogs adopt a mirror image of the RWDB style. Still, I can’t see the blogosphere doing much to advance the Liberal cause.

fn1. This isn’t a term of abuse from Ken, but an ironic self-description used by the RWDBs themselves.

fn2. I should also mention Bargarz, listed by Ken as a moderate, but who hasn’t posted on Australian politics for some time. Bernard Slattery teeters on the edge. He was part of the moderate right when I started out, but it is now classed by Ken with the RWDB group.

30 thoughts on “Where is the grown-up right ?

  1. It doesn’t matter if blogs are not read by most people. It could be interesting if blogs are read by journalists.

    Would, for instance, the Swift Boat crap have been picked over so thoroughly in the press if the bloggers hadn’t hadn’t smacked it about in much greater detail than any op-ed piece?

    Perhaps we could say the same about the children overboard fiasco?

    All it needs is smart journos (and policy wonks as Mark points out) to recognise they can get a good angle on something from a blogger, and our influence is disproportionate.

    The role of comments is crucial here because they offer an increasing opportunity for the relevant experts (perhaps the people in the next cubicle when the deal went down) to pop a position under cover of a nom-de-whatsit.. but I am not sure this is growing. And so far only a small part of the academic community has twigged to the possibilities, probably because they are overworked.

    People don’t tell lies if they are going to get caught. And I think the blogosphere makes that more likely.

  2. I might also suggest that the RWDB tag is a useful rhetorical device for the left much in the way that MOONBAT is used by those on the right. Having been aligned with those of the former by Ken and JQ who “dress to the left” themselves, I’m not too worried by it.

    Ken’s list is useful but the classifications are very subjective.

  3. Fear, loathing, etc #2
    This is the second general campaign, say-whatever-you-like that’s election-related, post (revised title adopted under pressure). Newspoll has the ALP ahead at 52/48, although the primary has slipped behind at 40/43. The ALP’s preferences are the differ…

  4. Fear, loathing, etc #2
    This is the second general campaign, say-whatever-you-like that’s election-related, post (revised title adopted under pressure). Newspoll has the ALP ahead at 52/48, although the primary has slipped behind at 40/43. The ALP’s preferences are the differ…

  5. Why do they hate America ?
    What kind of limpwristed surrender monkey would deride one of his own country’s most important military honours as being a bogus scheme cooked up for political purposes? Morton Blackwell, Republican of Virginia (and dozens of other delegates to t…

Comments are closed.