16 thoughts on “Monday message board

  1. Interesting to see Alan Kohler arguing that David Murray might be the one to split Telstra (see here). Can we hope that the market will lead to a reasonable public policy outcome after all?

  2. The question is who is falling for a hoax. It may be that an(two?) ambulance was struck by Israeli fire of some kind causing the casualties reported and we media consumers have been presented with some convenient pictures for that purpose. However if the ambulance pictured in reports is really supposed to be the target in question, then there are some serious doubts about the reported facts as raised. This may be a matter of rocket science vs propaganda and we’re entitled to the truth.

  3. For example from my linked News report above we have-

    ‘Last night, the group manager of the first-aid team for the Lebanese Red Cross, George Kettneh, insisted that two LRC ambulances had been attacked on the night of July 23, near Qana in southern Lebanon.

    “I was on duty that night and every ambulance that moved in Lebanon I had to know about,” he said.

    “I received phone calls from the ambulance drivers and it took us one hour to negotiate a ceasefire through the International Committee of the Red Cross.”

    Ambulance driver Qassem Shalim was closing the doors of the ambulance when the vehicle was hit.

    “I am sure the missile was fired from a drone. The blue light was flashing on our roof, the red cross was clear and there was a light on the Lebanese Red Cross flag above me. Everything I said happened did happen,” he told The Australian in Beirut.’

    Then from the Zombietime website Associated Press reports-

    ‘…the Lebanese Red Cross suspended operations outside Tyre after Israeli jets blasted two ambulances with rockets, said Ali Deebe, a Red Cross spokesman in Tyre.’

    Hmmm… rockets from Israeli jets OR drones eh Red Cross?

  4. “Hmmm… rockets from Israeli jets OR drones eh Red Cross?”

    Does it matter?

    What point exactly are you trying to make other than perhaps making a bid for the clutching at straws championship?

  5. There’s an excellent case made for it being a hoax on the site Dolly was tossing over. It’s a site with a pretty clear agenda, but not everything a ‘wierd dude’ says is to be discarded.

    Don’t let’s fall into the RWDB trap of only looking at the evidence that suits us, eh?

  6. No it doesn’t matter, negligence is not much of an excuse.

    If a drunk driver crashed into your car, killing your family, would you take solace from the fact he probably didn’t mean it?

  7. There is more in the Australian’s Media section today, considering the Oz’s Middle East correspondent was in the vicinity, I think he is a more reliable source than the zombie whatever-its-name-is website.


    “I was in Tyre on the night of the attack and investigated the incident closely the next day. On July 24, with photographer Stewart Innes, we spoke to Qassem Shalin, who was recovering from a minor wound to his chin that nurses had bandaged to stop it from turning septic. We also visited Ahmed Mohammed Fawaz, whose lower left leg had been amputated and whose severe burns ironically had saved his life by sealing blood vessels and arteries. His son writhed in pain nearby, his stomach riddled with shrapnel and the rear of his scalp opened up.

    We inspected both ambulances, whose mangled roofs were not rusting at the time. By the time the photos used on the blog site were taken, rust had appeared. But this is entirely normal in Lebanon’s sultry summer climate, where humidity on the coast does not drop below 70per cent.

    Downer’s spokesman, Tony Parkinson, said on Tuesday: “Those (website) pictures do not show an ambulance that has been struck by a missile nor do they sustain the argument the ambulance was struck by a missile.”

    He is wrong. The damage done was consistent with ruined cars and vans that I saw elsewhere in Lebanon and earlier in Gaza, which had been hit by a missile fired from a drone. The Israeli-made drones have many types of missiles, but the most regularly used has a small warhead designed for use in urban areas. It aims not to kill anyone outside a small zone and rarely leaves a calling card outside its target.

    Downer and Parkinson should know this. The Australian Government last year signed a deal to buy drones from Israel. They would surely have come with a buyer’s guide.”

  8. Stephen,

    that would be the small non exploding missile (ie a large bullet) theory?
    ZT accepted this was possible and I think it is quite likely. The problem however is it still holds up ZT’s main point that it was shoddy reporting as is the following.

    > where humidity on the coast does not drop below 70per cent.

    1) that is hard to believe since the weather reports have it far below 70% (check yourself)
    Also quana is not on the coast. Does this guy think we are idiots?

    > He is wrong. The damage done was consistent with ruined cars and vans that I saw elsewhere in Lebanon and earlier in Gaza, which had been hit by a missile fired from a drone.

    hmm it is still unusual, usually even these missiles cause a big hole in the roof – still i guess it was helped by the fact that it was shooting directly into an air vent.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s