Paddy packs it in?

This piece in Crikey includes what purports to be PP McGuinness’ resignation letter from the Sydney Morning Herald. I can’t say I regret this. While McGuinness still does good stuff occasionally, the defining characteristic of his columns for the past decade or so has been sprays of vitriol, directed at a large, but predictable, range of targets. Even if you like this kind of stuff, the blogosphere supplies more, and purer, vitriol than any newspaper columnist, rendering the contributions of people like Paddy largely obsolete.

10 thoughts on “Paddy packs it in?

  1. It is typical of the man that he should produce such a graceless, self important and egocentric resignation letter.

    He was a columnist for God’s sake. It makes no difference to him whether Fairfax is or is not a “chaotic and badly managed ..company”.

    “It is not only your fault, but that of the SMH and Fairfax journalistic staff generally.” If that is true, it should be true of him too, shouldn’t it?

    Then again, he wouldn’t think of himself as a journalist. He does not even have the minimal concern for economy, civility and truth which that battered profession accepts.

  2. Preceding his resignation was the SMH’s mooted downsizing of Paddy (no mean feat) to once a month. Nod as good as a wink to a blind man on a galloping horse.

    We all look forward to Padraic’s daily blogging. :0):0):0):0)

  3. He was drawing a terronly long bow in his last column when he in effect blamed Quentin Tarantino for the Abu Ghraib incident.

  4. As a leftist, I don’t mind the challenge of ploughing through some of the Right’s propaganda, but Paddy’s sneering gets a bit predictable after a while. Henderson and Hywood are just so-so.

    Ditto with the Dancing Bears and the Devines. Maybe it’s time for a different approach. Could the SMH offer David Flint a column? As Richard Ackland noted he’s really like a Restoration Comedy figure and may add a bit of fun to the debate.

  5. I agree with John’s comments on Paddy and the follow-up comments on Devine etc. However, I also find it depressing that on issues such as the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, the extent of extremism within Islam (where the extreme is very much the mainstream) and the war in Iraq, these actors are now talking far more sense that the vast majority of the left. When in the context of the UK, the Daily Mail etc start to sound far more rational than the increasingly political correct Guardian and the Independent, one can see just how far the left has declined (from dogmatic Marxism to cultural relativism and/or utopianism and mindless anti-globalisation). A white male telling a slightly racist joke now appears to be viewed as more of a crime than the appalling oppression of women, trade-unionists, religious minorities etc by Islamic societies. So much for solidarity.

  6. It was interesting thaT LOrd Paddy put the AO in the letter.

    Given that he was the best Economics Editor of both the AFand National Times and wasn’t bad at being a film critic.

  7. Good riddance paddy.
    What has astonished me is that paddy and others of his ilk have been paid six figure sums per annum to lecture us poor people about the immorality of the left.
    Did it take surgery to remove his snout from the trough?

  8. Good riddance paddy.
    What has astonished me is that paddy and others of his ilk have been paid six figure sums per annum to lecture us poor people about the immorality of the left.
    Did it take surgery to remove his snout from the trough?

  9. Good riddance paddy.
    What has astonished me is that paddy and others of his ilk have been paid six figure sums per annum to lecture us poor people about the immorality of the left.
    Did it take surgery to remove his snout from the trough?

  10. windbag waywardly wafting
    Occasionally I like a gloat. “”Dear Robert, Before you rang me the other day, I had been contemplating whether I wished to retain any connection with the Sydney Morning Herald, and with the increasingly chaotic and badly managed Fairfax company….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s