A sorry business

Brendan Nelson’s career as Leader of the Opposition looks to be over before he has even faced the Rudd government in Parliament, thanks to his equivocation over the issue of an apology to the Stolen Generation. If Nelson was fair dinkum about supporting an apology, given the appropriate words, he could have made a positive virtue of it, saying something like “This apology needs to come from the Parliament, not just the government. I’m willing to work with Mr Rudd in preparing a statement that will have unanimous support”.

As it is, he will end up being forced through every possible position from outright opposition to conditional support to the final stage when he’ll be forced to deal with the hardline rejectionists in his own ranks.

A unanimous vote of Parliament is essential here. If Nelson fails to take firm action (expulsion and withdrawal of endorsement) against any Liberal who crosses the floor, his failure as a leader will be complete.

Nelson’s problem is that denouncing the Stolen Generation is a cause celebre for the hardliners who gave him for the job and for the culture war dinosaurs (Quadrant, the Bennelong Group and so on) who cheered them on for years. In this sector of their parallel universe, the treatment of Aboriginal Australians was a successful exercise in Christian philanthropy until leftist do-gooders took over in the 1960s. They won’t let Nelson, who is basically a decent person, do the right thing, at least not without a fight.

It’s a pity. Most people are ready to move beyond ideological pointscoring and embrace any policy option that will actually deliver improved living standards and reconciliation. If we are going to move forward, we need to acknowledge how badly our country has failed in the past, and an apology is an essential element of this process.

129 thoughts on “A sorry business

  1. I chose to ignore Howard in my most recent post on the apology, and I think we should all do likewise. His silence is sufficient.

  2. Ah yes, the Australian electorate got it wrong four times. Little did we realize. Needless to say Ian, I dispute the accuracy of the remark.

    For the record, I remain entirely unconvinced that this “apology” is anything more than yet another utterly meaningless lefty gesture.

  3. It may have been meaningless to you, but it wasn’t addressed to you. it wasn’t meaningless to the people that it was addressed to, or to those capable of feeling empathy for those to whom it was addressed.

  4. A lot of closet racists defending Nelson’s speech are saying that Rudd “Started it” by talking about the “stubborn” silence of the previous government.

    If you want to play that game, I think you would have to say that Howard’s decision not to attend was the original shot across the bow.

    Let us hope Howard stays off the stage for a good, long time. I cannot see him getting a very pleasant reception anywhere in Australia for some time.

    Howard is soon heading off to the USA to pick up an award from the neoconservative American Enterprise Institute. He is also hoping to get a knighthood from the Queen in London. Maybe he should just remain overseas?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s